Internal Compliance Investigations: Protocol and Management

We design and manage your internal compliance investigations protocol: alert analysis, evidence collection, interviews, reporting to the control body and closure in line with the Whistleblower Protection Law. Rigor, confidentiality and legal safeguards.

Free consultation

We reply within 24 h

Acknowledgment of receipt
7 days
Maximum response period
3 months
Mandatory channel threshold
50 employees
Whistleblower Protection Law
Law 2/2023

Internal investigations by type of incident

Internal fraud, workplace harassment, conflicts of interest, corruption or information leaks: each type of investigation has its own methodology, deadlines and specific safeguards.

Internal fraud

Financial irregularities and misappropriation

“Internal fraud investigations require forensic analysis of accounting records and transactions, digital preservation of evidence and coordination with the legal department and the external auditors.”

Harassment and misconduct

Workplace harassment, sexual harassment or discrimination

“Harassment investigations call for special protection of the victim, reinforced confidentiality, forensic interview techniques and coordination with the company’s harassment protocol.”

Corruption

Bribery, graft and conflicts of interest

“Investigating corrupt conduct requires analyzing payments, gifts, relationships with third parties and undeclared conflicts of interest, with particular attention to the company’s regulatory exposure.”

Leaks

Information leaks and trade secrets

“Investigations into leaks of confidential information require digital traceability analysis, a review of access rights and action coordinated with the DPO so as not to breach data protection rules.”

What happens if you mishandle an internal investigation?

A poorly managed internal investigation can increase the company’s criminal liability, invalidate evidence and create labor and reputational disputes that are hard to resolve.

Corporate criminal liability: without a diligent internal investigation, the company cannot show that it reacted to the breach, a key factor for exemption from or mitigation of criminal liability.

Invalidated evidence: gathering evidence without respecting fundamental rights (confidentiality of communications, data protection) can make it inadmissible at trial and expose the company to lawsuits.

Labor disputes: a poorly conducted investigation can lead to unfair dismissals, violations of the right of defense and claims before the labor courts with high costs.

Whistleblower lawRetaliation prohibited

Law 2/2023 prohibits any retaliation against the whistleblower. Failing to protect them adequately can lead to penalties for the company and the loss of the protection the channel offers.

GDPR / LOPDGDDFines up to €20 million

Processing of personal data in an internal investigation must comply with data protection rules. Breaches in this area can lead to penalties from the Spanish Data Protection Agency (AEPD).

Criminal CodeArt. 31 bis

Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code allows a legal entity to be exempted from criminal liability if it demonstrates an effective compliance model and an adequate response to the breach.

Do you have to manage an internal investigation?

We assess the case, design the action protocol and manage the investigation with legal rigor: evidence, interviews, reporting and closure in line with the Whistleblower Protection Law and the Criminal Code.

Internal compliance investigations: common questions

What is an internal compliance investigation?

An internal compliance investigation is the formal, structured process by which a company investigates, confidentially and impartially, alleged breaches of its code of conduct, internal rules or applicable law.

It includes activating the protocol, collecting evidence, conducting interviews, legal analysis and preparing a conclusions report with corrective measures.

What does the Whistleblower Protection Law (Law 2/2023) require?

Law 2/2023 on the protection of persons who report regulatory breaches requires companies with 50 or more employees to have an internal whistleblowing channel, a procedure for handling reports with specific deadlines and measures to protect the whistleblower from retaliation.

  • Acknowledgment of receipt to the whistleblower within a maximum of 7 days.
  • A reasoned response within a maximum of 3 months.
  • An absolute ban on retaliation against the whistleblower.
  • The possibility of anonymous reporting.
Who should lead an internal investigation?

An internal investigation must be led by a person or team that is independent, impartial and has sufficient legal knowledge. In practice, this can be the compliance officer, a specialized outside lawyer or a combination of both.

Independence is key: if the person under investigation is a senior executive, we recommend outsourcing the investigation to ensure impartiality and protect the company against any later challenge.

How is confidentiality protected in an internal investigation?

Confidentiality is a fundamental principle of any internal compliance investigation. Usual measures include:

  • Restricting access to information to those who strictly need it.
  • Secure storage of documents and evidence.
  • Encrypted communications with those taking part in the investigation.
  • Confidentiality agreements with interviewees.
  • Protecting the whistleblower’s identity in line with Law 2/2023.
What evidence can be collected in an internal investigation?

The admissible evidence in an internal investigation can include corporate emails, system access logs, financial documents, internal communications and statements from interviewees.

However, evidence collection must respect employees’ fundamental rights: confidentiality of communications, data protection, privacy and the right not to incriminate oneself. Evidence obtained in breach of fundamental rights may be declared void and expose the company to liability.

How does an internal investigation relate to Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code?

Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code provides that a legal entity is exempt from criminal liability if, among other requirements, it adopted and effectively implemented an organizational model that included supervision, control and response measures for breaches.

  • The internal investigation is the evidence that the company reacted to the breach.
  • A well-documented investigation report is a key defense element before the prosecutor’s office.
  • The absence of an internal investigation can aggravate the company’s criminal liability.
What deadlines apply to the internal investigation procedure?

Deadlines in an internal compliance investigation depend on its complexity, but Law 2/2023 sets specific milestones for handling reports:

  • 7 days: acknowledgment of receipt of the report to the whistleblower.
  • 3 months: maximum period to inform the whistleblower of the action taken (extendable to 6 months in complex cases).
  • Complex investigations may need additional weeks or months for evidence collection and preparing the final report.
What happens with data protection in an internal investigation?

Processing personal data in an internal investigation is subject to the GDPR and the LOPDGDD. The company must be able to show a legal basis for the processing (generally legitimate interest or compliance with a legal obligation), inform the affected persons appropriately (within the limits the investigation imposes) and ensure the security of the data collected.

We recommend coordinating with the Data Protection Officer (DPO) before and during the investigation to avoid security breaches and AEPD penalties.

Practical guide to internal compliance investigations

An effective internal investigation does not start when the problem arises: it requires a prior protocol, a prepared team and an evidence management system that ensures the findings are legally admissible.

Preliminary phase

Protocol and preparation

Designing the investigation protocol in advance, appointing the investigating team and defining responsibilities and activation criteria. Without a prior protocol, the investigation loses rigor and traceability.

Investigation

Evidence collection and interviews

Obtaining documents, digital records and statements while respecting fundamental rights. A rigorous chain of custody and detailed documentation of every investigative step.

Closure

Report, measures and follow-up

Conclusions report with established facts, legal assessment and recommendations. Implementation of corrective and disciplinary measures, or measures to improve the compliance system.

Checklist: 10 steps for an effective internal compliance investigation

  1. Activate the internal investigation protocol and appoint an independent investigating team.
  2. Acknowledge receipt of the report to the whistleblower within the legal deadline (7 days) and ensure their protection from retaliation.
  3. Assess the report: determine whether the facts can be investigated and whether there is enough basis to open an investigation.
  4. Identify and preserve evidence immediately to prevent it from being altered or destroyed.
  5. Design the investigation plan: scope, methodology, planned interviews and deadlines.
  6. Coordinate with the DPO on the personal data processing framework that applies to the investigation.
  7. Interview witnesses and the persons under investigation using forensic technique, guaranteeing the right of defense.
  8. Analyze the evidence and cross-check it against the statements obtained in the interviews.
  9. Prepare the conclusions report with established facts, legal assessment and recommendations.
  10. Communicate the outcome to the whistleblower, implement corrective measures and close the file with full traceability.

If you need support with an internal investigation, see our corporate compliance services or request a free consultation.

Internal investigations in practice

From alert to report: operational building blocks of an internal investigation

An effective internal compliance investigation is organized into operational blocks with clear owners, defined deadlines and documentary traceability. These are the modules we design and oversee.

Internal investigations: whistleblowing channel1) Channel and alert

Whistleblowing channel and activation

Handling the alert from the moment it is received: classification, acknowledgment, preliminary assessment and a reasoned decision to investigate or close the file.

  • Secure, confidential receipt
  • Preliminary admissibility assessment
  • Documented decision to open the investigation
Internal investigations: digital evidence2) Evidence

Evidence collection and custody

Immediate preservation of documents, emails, access logs and communications. Chain of custody with probative value and GDPR compliance.

  • Forensic digital preservation
  • Documented chain of custody
  • Data protection compliance
Internal investigations: interviews3) Interviews

Investigative interviews with safeguards

Planning and conducting interviews with witnesses, whistleblowers and the persons under investigation. Forensic technique, right of defense and documentation of the interview record.

  • Order and technique of the interviews
  • Safeguards for the person under investigation
  • Documented interview records
Internal investigations: types of incidentBy type of incident

Methodology by type of incident

Fraud / Corruption

Financial forensic analysis, digital preservation, coordination with the external auditors and possible notification to the authorities.

Harassment / Misconduct

Reinforced protection of the victim, maximum confidentiality, interviews using specialized technique and immediate precautionary measures.

Leaks / Data

Digital traceability analysis, review of access rights, coordination with the DPO and assessment of the security breach.

Internal Investigations Playbook

Internal investigations: what each rule requires

Rule
What it requires
Typical evidence

Law 2/2023 (Whistleblower Protection)

Internal whistleblowing channel, a management procedure with deadlines, whistleblower protection and a ban on retaliation.

Channel policy, report register, acknowledgments of receipt, communications to the whistleblower, documentation of measures taken.

Criminal Code (Art. 31 bis)

An effective compliance model with supervision, control and a diligent response to breaches. The internal investigation is the evidence of that response.

Investigation protocol, conclusions report, corrective measures implemented, minutes of the control body.

GDPR / LOPDGDD

Legal basis for processing data in the investigation, information to the affected persons (with limits), data security and coordination with the DPO.

Record of processing activities, legal basis analysis, DPO report, documented security measures.

Workers’ Statute

The right of defense of the person under investigation, proportionality of disciplinary measures and compliance with the disciplinary dismissal procedure.

Letter of charges, prior hearing, employment law report, dismissal letter and documentation of the disciplinary process.

Anti-harassment protocol

Companies must have a protocol on workplace and sexual harassment. The internal investigation of these incidents must follow the established procedure.

Approved harassment protocol, register of harassment reports, investigation records, measures adopted and follow-up.

Warning signs in internal investigations

If you recognize any of these situations, you urgently need to review your internal compliance investigations protocol.

  • You have no documented internal investigation protocol approved by the control body.
  • Your whistleblowing channel does not meet the requirements of Law 2/2023 (deadlines, anonymity, whistleblower protection).
  • Investigations are led by the area affected by the incident, with no independence or impartiality.
  • You have no chain-of-custody procedure for the evidence collected.
  • You have not coordinated data processing in investigations with the company’s DPO.
Glossary

Key concepts in internal compliance investigations

If you are managing or designing an internal compliance investigations protocol, these terms appear in the regulations, in the procedures and in the company’s legal defense.

Internal investigationCore

Formal corporate investigation process

A structured, confidential process by which the company investigates alleged breaches of its internal rules or the law, with safeguards for the people under investigation and for whistleblowers.

A key element of the compliance model (Criminal Code Art. 31 bis).
Whistleblowing channelLaw 2/2023

Internal reporting system

A secure, confidential and accessible channel for employees and third parties to report alleged breaches. Mandatory for companies with 50 or more employees.

Acknowledgment deadline: 7 days. Response: 3 months.
WhistleblowerProtection

The person who files the report

An individual who reports violations and has legal protection against retaliation: dismissal, sanction, harassment or any measure that harms them for having reported.

Protection guaranteed by Law 2/2023 and Directive (EU) 2019/1937.
Chain of custodyEvidence

Controlling the integrity of evidence

A documented record of everyone who has accessed, held or transferred a piece of evidence, to ensure its integrity and admissibility in judicial or regulatory proceedings.

Essential for evidence to carry probative value.
Criminal Code Art. 31 bisCriminal

Exemption from corporate criminal liability

The article of the Criminal Code that sets the conditions for a legal entity to be exempt from liability: an effective compliance model and a diligent response to breaches.

The internal investigation is the evidence of the required response.
Due processSafeguards

Right of defense of the person under investigation

The set of safeguards that must be respected during the internal investigation: presumption of innocence, the right to be heard, access to relevant information and proportionality of the measures adopted.

Violating them can invalidate the process and lead to labor claims.
Compliance officerRole

Regulatory compliance officer

The person responsible for the company’s compliance system, including oversight of the whistleblowing channel and the direction or supervision of internal investigations.

Must have independence, resources and direct access to the control body.
RetaliationProhibited

A harmful measure against the whistleblower

Any act or omission that harms the whistleblower as a result of their report: dismissal, sanction, change of position, harassment, exclusion, unjustified negative evaluation.

Expressly prohibited by Law 2/2023. Creates liability for the company.
Conclusions reportClosure

Final document of the internal investigation

A report setting out the established facts, the legal analysis, the responsibilities identified and the recommendations for corrective or disciplinary measures or improvements to the compliance model.

First line of defense before the prosecutor’s office and the regulatory authority.

INTERNAL INVESTIGATIONS · COMPLIANCE CONSOLE

Maturity panel: internal investigations by company size

The level of requirement for internal compliance investigations varies with company size, sector and regulatory exposure. This panel summarizes the obligations and risk level by profile.

Matrix of obligations by size and sector

Identify your profile and prioritize the elements of the internal investigations protocol.

Element
Large company / Listed
Mid-sized company
SME (<50 employees)
Whistleblowing channel
MandatoryLaw 2/2023
MandatoryIf 50+ employees
VoluntaryRecommended
Investigation protocol
NecessaryCriminal Code Art. 31 bis
RecommendedReduces criminal risk
AdvisableBest practice
DPO coordination
MandatoryIf a DPO is appointed
RecommendedGDPR
AdvisableDepends on activity

Book a call

Tell us about your situation and we will explain how to manage an internal investigation with legal rigor, confidentiality and safeguards for your company.

Internal compliance investigations: legal and operational framework

Internal compliance investigations are the mechanism by which a company reacts diligently to alleged breaches of its internal rules or the law. In the context of Spanish and European corporate compliance, the internal investigation has gone from being an option to an essential element of the compliance model.

The Whistleblower Protection Law and the whistleblowing channel

Law 2/2023 of February 20 transposes European Directive 2019/1937 and requires companies with 50 or more employees to have a secure, confidential and accessible internal whistleblowing channel. The law sets specific response deadlines, prohibits any retaliation against the whistleblower and guarantees the possibility of anonymous reporting. Non-compliance can lead to fines of up to €300,000 for legal entities.

Internal investigation and corporate criminal liability

Article 31 bis of the Criminal Code provides that a legal entity is exempt from criminal liability if it adopted and effectively implemented an organizational model with supervision, control and response measures for breaches. The internal compliance investigation is the evidence that the company reacted diligently to the breach detected. Without a documented internal investigation, the company loses one of its main defense arguments before the prosecutor’s office.

Data protection in internal investigations

Processing personal data in an internal investigation is subject to the GDPR and the LOPDGDD. The company must identify the legal basis for the processing, inform the affected persons appropriately (within the limits the investigation imposes), ensure data security and coordinate its actions with the Data Protection Officer. A breach in this area can lead to AEPD penalties and the nullity of the evidence obtained.

Safeguards for the person under investigation and labor law

An internal investigation must respect the right of defense of the person under investigation: presumption of innocence, the right to be heard and proportionality of the measures adopted. In the employment context, a disciplinary dismissal that follows an internal investigation must meet the requirements of the Workers’ Statute to avoid being classified as unfair or void.

Internal investigation Compliance Law 2/2023 Whistleblowing channel Criminal Code Art. 31 bis Whistleblowing Evidence GDPR

Official sources

Key legislation, linked to the official text:

Legislation and links reviewed in .