Broker-dealer or securities broker?
“A broker-dealer can deal on its own account; a securities broker, only on behalf of third parties. If your model takes proprietary positions, the firm type and the capital change.”
A broker-dealer (sociedad de valores) is the most complete type of investment firm: it can deal on its own account and on behalf of third parties and provide all investment services. Capital: €750,000. We help you with regulatory fit, the CNMV application and compliance.
Free consultation
We reply within 24 h
Six building blocks that make up a coherent, defensible CNMV application to authorize the most complete investment firm: the one that can deal both on its own account and on behalf of third parties.
We analyze whether your model requires a broker-dealer (own account, €750,000) or is a better fit as a securities broker (agencia de valores), a portfolio management company or an EAF/EAFN, depending on the investment services you will provide.
We prepare the application file: program of activities, fit and proper assessment of directors, corporate structure, capital, internal policies and responses to requests for information, for a solid process.
We design a robust organization: fit and proper directors, compliance functions, risk management (including proprietary portfolio risk) and internal audit.
We implement client classification, suitability and appropriateness, best execution, conflict-of-interest management and the separation between own-account and client business.
As a financial obliged entity, a broker-dealer must implement the AML/CFT framework: risk assessment, KYC, monitoring, SEPBLAC representative and training.
We organize outsourcing, SLAs, business continuity and DORA compliance, which applies to investment firms authorized in the EU.
Brokers dealing on their own account, market makers, execution platforms or managers who want the broadest license: the broker-dealer has its own regulatory fit and specific requirements.
“A broker-dealer can deal on its own account; a securities broker, only on behalf of third parties. If your model takes proprietary positions, the firm type and the capital change.”
“Authorization is not won with polished paperwork: it takes consistency between business, capital, governance, risk management, conduct and technology.”
“Dealing on own account adds market and solvency risk. Control of the proprietary portfolio and of conflicts with clients is central to the application.”
“Authorization is not the end. An investment firm needs operational AML/CFT, internal control, reporting to the CNMV and constant monitoring from day one.”
Providing investment services without authorization, filing an inconsistent application, or neglecting MiFID II conduct and proprietary portfolio risk management can halt your business and expose you to penalties.
The most common mistake: underestimating what dealing on own account involves. A broker-dealer takes on market and solvency risk, which raises the capital, control and reporting requirements.
The CNMV reviews consistency, not just documents: if the business model, capital, fit and proper, MiFID II conduct, risk management and outsourcing do not fit together, the application loses strength and requests for information multiply.
Conflicts of interest are closely watched: when you deal on your own account and on behalf of clients at the same time, segregation of duties and the conflicts policy are core components, not annexes.
Providing reserved investment services without CNMV authorization can lead to the activity being halted and to sanctioning proceedings.
The LMV classifies the unauthorized performance of reserved activities as a very serious infringement, with liability for directors.
Markets, counterparties and partners require an active CNMV authorization before you operate: without it, agreements are blocked.
Before opening the application, it is worth validating the scope of investment services, deciding whether you need to deal on your own account and checking whether the structure can meet the requirements for capital, governance, MiFID II conduct, risk management, AML/CFT and ongoing control.
A broker-dealer (sociedad de valores) is an investment firm (ESI) and, among investment firms, the most complete type: it can provide all investment services and the ancillary services provided for by law. Its distinctive feature is that it is authorized to deal on its own account, as well as on behalf of third parties.
It is subject to authorization, registration and supervision by the CNMV and, as a financial institution, it is an obliged entity for anti-money laundering purposes.
The essential difference is on whose behalf they operate:
The broader scope of a broker-dealer means more risk and, therefore, a higher minimum capital.
The initial capital of a broker-dealer is €750,000, under the current implementing regulations (Royal Decree 813/2023). It is the highest among investment firms, precisely because a broker-dealer can deal on its own account.
On top of that initial capital come the own funds and solvency requirements arising from the prudential framework for investment firms.
The current framework is Law 6/2023 on Securities Markets and Investment Services (LMV) and its implementing regulation, Royal Decree 813/2023, which repealed the former Royal Decree 217/2008. On top of this come the MiFID II conduct rules and anti-money laundering legislation.
Authorization, registration and supervision are the responsibility of the CNMV.
It can provide the full range of investment services: reception and transmission of orders, execution, dealing on own account, portfolio management, advice, placing and underwriting of issues, as well as ancillary services (including safekeeping and administration of financial instruments), within the scope authorized in its program of activities.
Yes. As one of its ancillary services, it can provide safekeeping and administration of financial instruments on behalf of clients, subject to the safeguarding and asset segregation obligations imposed by the rules. Clients’ securities and cash accounts must be properly identified and segregated.
Yes. Investment firms are financial obliged entities under Law 10/2010. They must implement a full AML/CFT system: risk assessment, due diligence (KYC), monitoring, SEPBLAC representative, training and, where applicable, an external expert review.
It depends on the complexity of the project and the quality of the application. Because a broker-dealer deals on its own account and may hold client assets, the scrutiny of capital, solvency and risk control is more intense, which can lengthen the process.
A coherent, complete application from the start is the best way to shorten timelines and reduce requests for information.
Yes. Every authorized investment firm is entered in the CNMV official register, which is public and searchable. Registration is a condition for operating and allows clients and counterparties to verify that the firm is authorized and to see the scope of its services.
It means trading with the firm’s own assets, taking positions and market risk, as opposed to executing orders on behalf of clients. It is the power that distinguishes a broker-dealer from a securities broker, and it requires enhanced risk and conflict-of-interest controls.
Broker-dealers are subject to the Investment Guarantee Fund (FOGAIN) regime, which compensates investors in certain cases of insolvency or default by the firm, within the limits set by law.
Yes, through the MiFID II EU passport: an investment firm authorized in Spain can provide services in the rest of the EEA under the free provision of services or through a branch, by notifying the CNMV, without a new authorization in each State.
Yes. It can appoint agents to promote business or provide services on its behalf, but it must notify those agency relationships to the CNMV and keep a documentary record. The firm is liable for its agents’ actions.
Because it acts on its own account and on behalf of clients at the same time, it must have a conflicts of interest policy, segregation of duties, information barriers and records showing that the client’s interest prevails. This is one of the areas the CNMV watches most closely.
There is no single fee: the cost depends on the regulatory capital required and the complexity of the application. We help you size it before you start.
The total cost of setting up a broker-dealer combines two blocks: the regulatory capital required by law and the structuring cost of the project and the application.
Before committing to fees, we settle the regulatory fit and the real scope of the project. That way you avoid paying for work you do not need and get a realistic estimate of effort and timelines.
| Firm type (ESI) | Initial capital | Own account? | Asset custody? | Key feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Broker-dealer (sociedad de valores) | €750,000 | Yes | Yes (if authorized) | The most complete investment firm: own account and on behalf of third parties |
| Securities broker (agencia de valores) | €150,000 | No | Yes (if authorized) or operating an MTF/OTF | Only on behalf of third parties |
| Simplified securities broker (agencia de valores simplificada) | €75,000 | No | No | No custody of client money or securities |
| Portfolio management company (SGC) | €75,000 | No | No | Portfolio management and advice |
| EAF (financial advisory firm) | €75,000 | No | No | Investment advice only |
| EAFN (national) | €50,000 or liability insurance | No | No | National-scope advice |
Initial capital figures under Royal Decree 813/2023. An EAFN may replace capital with professional liability insurance (minimum cover of €1,000,000 per claim and €1,500,000 per year) or an equivalent guarantee. The exact fit and solvency requirements depend on the specific services to be provided; it is advisable to validate them case by case before starting the application.
Authorization is not just a formality: it is a system that must demonstrate consistency between business model, capital, governance, risk management, MiFID II conduct and evidence. The key is to build, from the outset, a firm that can withstand real supervision.
Not just the business idea. It analyzes whether the structure can support it: sufficient capital and solvency, fit and proper directors, key functions, proprietary portfolio risk management and real operational capacity.
Dealing on own account adds market and solvency risk and multiplies conflicts of interest with clients. Its controls must be designed before the application, not after.
MiFID II conduct, operational AML/CFT, DORA, reporting to the CNMV, audits and handling of requests for information must be designed to last over time, not just to get through the initial application.
If you want to structure your application from scratch or review the current status of your project, see our securities market regulation services or our corporate compliance practice.
An effective broker-dealer is not a dossier: it is a set of coherent decisions (regulatory fit, capital and solvency, MiFID II conduct, proprietary portfolio risk management, AML/CFT, governance and outsourcing) demonstrated through traceability. Here is a visual panel to understand how it works in practice.
1) FitThe goal is not to “get the license faster”: it is to make sure the model really needs to deal on its own account, and with what scope. That decision shapes capital and the application.
2) ApplicationThe CNMV reviews consistency. The program of activities, capital, fit and proper, policies, technology and outsourcing must fit together without internal contradictions.
3) Risk and conductDealing on own account requires controlling market risk, solvency and conflicts with clients. When this is designed late, it weakens the authorization or creates structural gaps.
4) ComplianceMiFID II conduct, operational AML/CFT, DORA, audits and reporting turn the company into a real firm: monitoring, corrections and living evidence from day one.
Quick decisionBroker-dealer: you deal on your own account and on behalf of third parties. Capital €750,000.
Securities broker (€150,000) or simplified securities broker without custody (€75,000).
EAF/EAFN or SGC: advice or portfolio management without dealing on own account.
A reasoned analysis showing that the activity requires a broker-dealer and not another firm type, with its scope (own account, custody, services).
Regulatory fit report, service description and comparison of investment firm types.
Evidence of the initial capital (€750,000) and of a prudential framework proportionate to the proprietary portfolio risk.
Proof of capital, financial plan and solvency projections.
Client classification, suitability and appropriateness, information, best execution and separation of own-account and client business.
Conduct procedures, best execution policy and conflicts of interest register.
Risk assessment, onboarding, monitoring and reporting proportionate to the firm’s profile.
AML/CFT manual, KYC files, alert log and evidence of staff training.
Fit and proper directors, key functions, risk management and an internal control system.
Minutes, appointments, conflicts policy, risk map and annual audit plan.
Spot them before filing the application to avoid costly requests for information.
If you are structuring a broker-dealer (sociedad de valores), these terms come up in the application, in internal policies and in dealings with the CNMV. Understanding them well helps you build a coherent project.
A firm authorized by the CNMV to provide investment services: broker-dealers, securities brokers, portfolio management companies and financial advisory firms.
An investment firm that can provide all investment services and deal both on its own account and on behalf of third parties. Initial capital of €750,000.
Trading with the firm’s own assets, taking positions and market risk. It is the power that distinguishes a broker-dealer from a securities broker.
European investor protection framework: client classification, suitability and appropriateness, information, best execution, conflicts of interest and product governance.
Ancillary service of holding and administering financial instruments on behalf of clients, with asset segregation and safeguarding. A broker-dealer may provide it if authorized.
Investor compensation scheme for certain cases of insolvency or default by an investment firm. Broker-dealers are subject to its contribution regime.
A set of measures to prevent the firm’s own interest from harming the client, especially when it deals on its own account and on behalf of third parties at the same time.
The core document of the application: it describes the investment services to be provided, the operating structure, the markets, the clients and the partners of the future firm.
EU regulation requiring an ICT risk management framework, business continuity, incident reporting and oversight of critical providers.
Tell us about your project and we will explain how to structure your broker-dealer so it works in practice, with the shortest possible authorization timeline.
Investment firms, including broker-dealers, are regulated by Law 6/2023 on Securities Markets and Investment Services and its implementing regulation, Royal Decree 813/2023, which repealed the former Royal Decree 217/2008. Authorization, registration and supervision are the responsibility of the CNMV, which assesses the suitability of the project, solvency, corporate governance and the strength of the application.
A broker-dealer is the investment firm that can provide all investment services and operate both on behalf of clients and on its own account. That power—dealing with its own assets—distinguishes it from a securities broker, which only operates on behalf of others, and explains why it is subject to higher capital and risk control requirements.
Royal Decree 813/2023 sets the initial capital for each investment firm: broker-dealer €750,000; securities broker €150,000 (also if authorized to operate an MTF/OTF); securities broker not authorized to hold client money or securities €75,000; portfolio management company and EAF €75,000; and EAFN €50,000, which can be replaced by professional liability insurance with minimum cover of €1,000,000 per claim and €1,500,000 per year.
Every broker-dealer is subject to the MiFID II conduct of business rules: client classification, suitability and appropriateness assessment, pre-contractual information, best execution of orders, conflict-of-interest management and product governance. If it provides the ancillary custody service, it must safeguard and segregate client assets. In addition, as a financial institution, it is an obliged entity for anti-money laundering purposes under Law 10/2010.
Key legislation, linked to the official text:
Legislation and links reviewed in .